Why I Never Buy Supplements on Amazon (And You Shouldn't Either)
- Jaime Heer, FNTP, RWS
- Dec 16
- 4 min read
I get it—Amazon is convenient. Prime shipping, competitive prices, and everything you need in one place. But when it comes to supplements, that convenience could be costing you way more than money.
Let me be clear: I'm not trying to push products on you. I became a Functional Supplement Specialist specifically because the supplement world is confusing as hell, and I wanted to make sure what I recommend to my clients actually works. What I'm about to share comes from that education and from seeing too many clients waste money on products that literally do nothing—or worse, contain things they shouldn't.
The Amazon (and Costco, and CVS and TikTok) Supplement Problem
Here's what most people don't realize about buying supplements from big-box retailers and online marketplaces:
1. Counterfeit Products Are Everywhere (Especially on Amazon)
Amazon's marketplace model means third-party sellers can list products right alongside legitimate ones. Counterfeit supplements look identical to the real thing—same packaging, same label—but inside? Who knows. Studies have found that up to 40% of supplements sold through unauthorized third-party sellers are fake or expired. You could be taking rice powder in a fancy bottle.
2. Storage Conditions Destroy Potency
Supplements are sensitive. Heat, light, and humidity degrade their effectiveness—especially probiotics, omega-3s, and anything with live cultures or delicate compounds. Amazon warehouses aren't climate-controlled supplement storage facilities. Your probiotics might have been sitting in a 100-degree warehouse all summer. By the time they reach you, those "billion CFUs" on the label? Mostly dead.
And Costco? CVS? Those pallets sitting under fluorescent lights in un-temperature-controlled storage rooms aren't doing your supplements any favors either.
Oxidation is real. When supplements are stored improperly, fats go rancid, vitamins break down, and what you're swallowing becomes, at best, ineffective—at worst, potentially harmful.
3. Big-Box Brands Cut Corners on Quality
The supplements you find at Costco and CVS are often manufactured by companies prioritizing shelf stability and profit margins over bioavailability and ingredient quality. They use synthetic forms of vitamins, cheap fillers, and binders that your body struggles to absorb.
That magnesium oxide at CVS? Your body absorbs maybe 4% of it. The rest? Literally flushed down the toilet.
4. Instagram and TikTok Supplements Are Marketing, Not Medicine
Let's talk about those aesthetically pleasing supplement brands flooding your feed. You know the ones—gorgeous packaging, influencer codes, before-and-after testimonials, and promises that sound too good to be true.
Let me remind you that marketing budget does not equal quality ingredients.
Many of these direct-to-consumer brands spend more on Instagram ads and influencer partnerships than they do on third-party testing, quality sourcing, or bioavailable forms of nutrients. They're designed to look good and go viral—not necessarily to work.
I've seen clients spend hundreds on trendy "hormone balance" or "gut health" supplements from social media brands, only to discover (when we actually look at the label together) that they're getting:
Proprietary blends that hide how much of each ingredient you're actually getting
Ineffective forms of vitamins and minerals
Doses so low they're essentially placebo
Fillers, artificial colors, and additives that can actually worsen gut issues
The worst part is that most of these companies have zero transparency about their manufacturing processes, third-party testing, or ingredient sourcing. But they have really pretty bottles and a discount code from your favorite influencer.
5. You're Literally Flushing Money Down the Toilet
If your supplements have been degraded, counterfeited, or improperly formulated, your body isn't absorbing what it needs. You're paying for something that doesn't work. That's not "saving money"—that's expensive pee and zero results.
And if your health goal is actually to feel better, taking ineffective supplements means staying stuck in that cycle of fatigue, digestive issues, hormonal chaos, or whatever brought you here in the first place.
So Where Should You Buy Supplements?
Go straight to the manufacturer whenever possible. This ensures you're getting the real product, stored correctly, with proper handling from production to your door.
Or, shop from a practitioner-verified dispensary. I use Fullscript for my clients and personally because:
Products are stored in climate-controlled facilities
You get practitioner-grade supplements (the same ones we use in functional medicine practices)
You're getting bioavailable forms your body can actually use
Third-party testing is standard, not optional
You get 20% off your first order and 15% off everything thereafter
I've curated my Fullscript dispensary with my favorite supplements—the ones I trust, the ones I've researched, the ones I actually recommend. But you don't have to buy from me. Seriously. Just please, please don't buy your probiotics from a random Amazon seller, grab whatever's on sale at Costco, or fall for the latest TikTok trend with a pastel package.
My Goal Isn't to Sell You Stuff
My goal is to help you feel better and protect your health for the long term. The supplement industry is full of toxic ingredients, misleading labels, and companies that just want your money. I spent time becoming a Functional Supplement Specialist so I could cut through the noise and guide people toward what actually works.
If you're confused about what supplements you actually need—or if you're already taking a bunch and not seeing results—I can help with that.
Need Help Figuring Out What Your Body Actually Needs?
If you want a personalized supplement protocol based on your specific health concerns, goals, or even lab results, I offer Supplement Strategy Sessions.
We'll look at what you're currently taking, what's working (or not), and create a plan that makes sense for your body—not just what's trending on wellness TikTok.
Your health is worth more than convenience or cute packaging. Choose quality. Choose transparency. Choose supplements that actually do what they promise.
Comments